AC Valhalla Gudrun or Holger – Who to Choose? – Blame and Sail Choices

In Blame and Sail quest, you’ll come across a decision that you’d have to make. This quest will start in Ravensthorpe. You’ll need to decide who is right Gudrun or Holger in AC Valhalla. They’ll have a dispute over sailcloth, which you have to resolve. Your decision in this quest won’t matter whether who’s right or wrong, as Sigurd will have his own decision. The main choice comes in when Sigurd makes his decision and you have to choose whether you agree with his decision or not. This decision will impact your game’s ending. In this article, we’ll discuss who should you side with, Gudrun or Holger in AC Valhalla, what choice should you make, and more.

1. Gudrun or Holger – Who is right in the Blame and Sail quest in AC Valhalla?

AC Valhalla Gudrun or Holger - Who to Choose? - Blame and Sail Choices
Gudrun and Holger

In the Blame and Sail quest, you’ll have to decide who’s right in the dispute between Gudrun and Holger. They’ll be having a dispute over sailcloth. You start this quest once you enter the longhouse while Sigurd is also in Ravensthorpe. You’ll be given a task by Randvi to resolve the dispute that’s going on between Gudrun and Holger. You’ll need to listen to both sides of the story.

Gudrun will explain how Holger stole the sailcloth and destroyed it and she will ask him to pay her back. On the other hand, Holger says that he mistook the sailcloth to be abandoned goods and thus he took it. Holger also says in his defense that why would he display the sailcloth if he would’ve stolen it. Now that you’ve heard both sides of the story, you need to decide whether who’s right.

While you decide on who’s right, it won’t matter as Sigurd will interrupt in between and give the final decision. He would want to know why wasn’t The Jarl summoned. He will also be furious with Eivor as to why he’s taking his role. Sigurd will declare Holger a thief and he would ask him to pay 30 sailcloths to Gudrun as a punishment. This is where you have to make an important choice. As Sigurd makes the decision, Holger will ask you to do something about Sigurd’s unfair decision. You’ll be given two choices here –

  • This judgment is unfair.
  • I support Sigurd’s judgment.
AC Valhalla Gudrun or Holger - Who to Choose? - Blame and Sail Choices
Sigurd’s Judgment

I. What Choice Should you Make?

You need to remember, that the decision you make here will affect your game’s ending. You should choose the “I support Sigurd’s judgment” choice here. If you choose this choice, he’ll be happy with you and will bring you closer to the game’s ending. No matter which choice you choose, The Jarl will declare Holger guilty and punish him.

If you choose the “The judgment is unfair” choice, there will be an argument between you and Sigurd during the Holger trial. Choosing this choice will result in a strike with Sigurd and will lead to a different game ending. He won’t return to England with you in the “A Brother’s Keeper” quest of the “In The Hall of The Slain” story arc.

2. About Assassin’s Creed Valhalla

Assassin’s Creed Valhalla is the twelfth major installment in the Assassin’s Creed series, developed by Ubisoft Montreal and published by Ubisoft in 2020. The game is an action role-playing video game set in 872–878 AD. It is based on a fictional story during the Viking expansions into the British Isles. Players get to play Eivor Varinsdottir, a Viking raider fighting for peace and order among the Assassin Brotherhood.

The modern-day portion of the story is set in the 21st century. It portrays Layla Hassan, an Assassin who relives Eivor’s memories to find a way to save the Earth from destruction. The game is available on Microsoft Windows, PlayStation 4, Xbox One, Xbox Series X and Series S, Stadia, and PlayStation 5.

Some links on this page are affiliate links. This means that if you choose to make a purchase, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. For more information, Go here

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.